XenneX/LLC
All posts
By Buddy Delaune

App Review Wanted the Price First: PlaySori 1.0.2

Apple sent PlaySori back over its paywall: the free trial looked bigger than the price, and grown-ups lost their way in after subscribing. Here's the fix.

#playsori#app store#app review#subscriptions#paywall design
A blank paper price tag tied with string to the handle of a closed wooden toy box on a wooden floor, with a glowing crescent moon nightlight, a teddy bear and scattered wooden blocks behind it

A few weeks ago I wrote about what Apple's Kids Category kept out of PlaySori: no third-party SDKs, a purchase layer I built myself, and a parental gate in front of the only screen with words on it. That post was about privacy rules. I'd budgeted for at least one rejection.

It came on November 4, and it had nothing to do with privacy. Apple flagged two things, both on the grown-up side of the app. Neither was a big change in code. Both were things I should have caught.

The Trial Was Louder Than the Price

PlaySori has three plans: Yearly at $29.99, Monthly at $3.99, and Forever at $49.99 once. The two subscriptions start with seven days free.

Here's how a plan card looked in 1.0.1. The biggest, boldest text was the plan name, "Yearly." Under it, one line in a smaller size: "7 days free, then $29.99/year." The button said "Start free trial."

Read that the way a reviewer does. The line opens with the free trial. The button says "free." The amount you'll actually be charged sits at the end of a sentence, no bigger than the trial in front of it.

Apple's subscription guidance is blunt about this: "the amount that will be billed must be the most prominent pricing element in the layout." The rejection cited guideline 3.1.2(c), and it was right.

The embarrassing part is that I knew. My compliance checklist has a line for exactly this rule, and in October I left it unticked with a note that price and trial "share one line in the same size today" and it "needs a human eye." Then I submitted anyway. The checklist did its job. I didn't.

What the Card Says Now

Each plan card now has three lines instead of two:

  • The plan name, smaller now: "Yearly."
  • The billed amount, by far the biggest text on the card: "$29.99/year."
  • A smaller note under it: "Starts with 7 days free."

The button says "Subscribe." The Forever plan follows the same pattern: "$49.99" big, "Pay once, keep forever" small.

None of it is clever. It's the same information in a different order, with the size doing the talking. The trial is still there, and it's still a good reason to try the app. It just isn't the headline anymore.

A Test for "Biggest"

I didn't want to fix this by eye and then break it six months from now while adjusting a layout. So there's a test now that walks every plan card and fails if any text on it is as big as the price.

There's a second one that checks every plan's price, note and title fit on one line, with and without the trial. A localized price can run longer than "$29.99," and a price that wraps onto two lines is a quieter price.

The first version of that test also checked that the price was bold. It failed.

The Font Only Has One Weight

The grown-up screen uses Fredoka, a soft, rounded font that matches the rest of the app, and PlaySori only includes its SemiBold weight. There's no real bold to switch to. Rather than let Unity fake one, the app's UI kit switches any bold text back to normal when it applies the font.

So every line on that card is the same weight, whatever the code says. Size is the only lever I have. The price is set at 60 units against 40 for everything else, which on a landscape phone is roughly 22 points next to 14.5. The test now checks size only, and that's the honest version: it tests what the screen actually shows, not what the code asked for.

The Moon Disappeared

The second problem was guideline 2.1(a), and the reviewer's note said it plainly: parental access disappeared after subscribing.

Grown-ups get into PlaySori through a small moon in the corner of the playroom. Tap it, pass the gate (hold for three seconds, then a times-table question written out in words), and you reach the plans. In 1.0.1, the moon hid once the app was unlocked. There was nothing left to sell, so why leave a door in the corner of a kid's screen?

Because selling isn't the only thing behind that door. A parent who's subscribed still needs to restore a purchase on a new iPad, cancel before a renewal, or read the privacy policy. I'd removed the way to do all of that the moment they paid me.

Now the moon always shows in the playroom. It still hides inside the toys themselves, same as before. Behind the gate, an unlocked app gets its own page instead of the plans: "Every toy is unlocked," a Manage Subscription button that opens the store's subscription settings, Restore Purchases, and the privacy and terms links.

That page also covers a case I hadn't thought about. If the app unlocks while the plans are on screen, say a restore finishes or a parent approves an Ask to Buy request from their own phone, the screen used to just close. Now it switches to the unlocked page, so the grown-up can see it worked.

What I'm Taking From It

Both fixes came from the same blind spot. I designed the grown-up screen as a place to buy something. Apple treats it as the place a parent manages their relationship with the app, before and after they pay. That's a better way to think about it, and it's the one I'd start with next time.

PlaySori 1.0.2 has both fixes. If you're building an app with subscriptions and want a second set of eyes before you submit, I build mobile apps, and I've now been rejected for this so you don't have to be.

Working on something like this? See mobile app development or what XenneX has built.

Keep reading